Tami Treuheit

Sanibel Island Insurance


Tami Treuheit – Personal Lines Producer – Condo Specialist
Licensed 2-20 Agent


Tami has been with Heidrick & Co. Insurance since 2015. She began as the Administrative Receptionist, and was promoted to Personal Lines Producer the following year.


Tami has a vast knowledge of many of the residential condominium associations in the area and has become the agency’s Condo Specialist.  She is the go-to person when a client is purchasing a condo unit, whether it is to be used as a primary home, secondary home or as rental property.  In additional to writing condo insurance, Tami writes coverage for single family homes, autos, boats and more.  She is involved with the Sanibel-Captiva Islands Association of Realtors.


While Tami is relatively new to the insurance industry, she has an impressive background in client service.  Prior to joining Heidrick & Co., she worked for Captiva Cruises and a number of medical offices in in Florida and Indiana.


Tami is originally from Noblesville, Indiana. She currently lives in Fort Myers with her husband, Jeff.  She has four adult daughters – and six grandchildren – all of whom live in the Midwest.


Tami, enjoys spending time with her family and friends, traveling, decorating, home improvement projects and spending time on the water on her boat.